Start here

Identify one disputed item and request five things in writing: the decision, its scope, the facts relied on, the stated basis and the calculation. Then compare the reply with your records. Separate what is unanswered from what you understand but dispute, and keep deadlines separate from ordinary follow-ups.

What you can do with this guide

  • Ask what was decided, what it covers, why and how the amount was calculated.
  • Mark each answer as missing, incomplete or understood but disputed.
  • Bring the actual decision and release—not just a verbal summary—when seeking individual advice.

“That is all we can pay.” “It is not covered.” “The file is closed.” Those answers can leave you staring at a bill or offer without knowing what to challenge. You need more than a label. You need to know what the insurer decided and how it reached that position.

Ask for an answer you can actually check. Name the disputed item, the relevant dates and the documents that matter. Then request the decision, its scope, facts, stated basis and calculation. This guide turns those five fields into a focused message and shows what to do with the response.

The NAIC recommends asking for written explanations of adjuster decisions. Obtaining an explanation does not establish that the insurer is wrong, but it gives your next conversation something concrete to address.

Start with the decision you need explained

Before writing, identify the insurer, claim number, crash date and person or team handling the particular issue. Use the company name on the claim correspondence; an insurance agency, repair shop and insurer may have different responsibilities.

Then finish this sentence: “I need a written explanation of the decision about ______.” Be specific: the rental period after October 12, a repair operation left out of an estimate, a deduction in a vehicle valuation, or the insurer’s position about responsibility for the collision.

If one claim number includes several issues, list them separately. Vehicle damage, rental expenses and an injury claim can be handled by different people. A response about one does not necessarily tell you the position on the others. Ask who can answer each unresolved item rather than sending the same broad demand to everyone.

Finally, identify whether you are seeking benefits under a policy that covers you or asking the other driver’s insurer to pay. That distinction affects which policy provisions and claims procedures may apply. Do not copy a deadline or demand from an unrelated homeowner or health-insurance appeal.

Use this five-field decision worksheet

This is an organizing tool, not an official form or a list of documents every insurer must provide in every state. Fill in what you already know. Mark missing information “not explained” instead of guessing.

On a phone, swipe across the table to read all columns.

Five fields that make an insurance decision easier to check
FieldWhat to askWhat a useful answer lets you do
1. DecisionHas this item been accepted, denied, partly accepted, or left pending? Is this a proposed settlement or a payment determination?Separate an actual refusal from an unfinished review or an offer.
2. ScopeWhich coverage, expense, repair item, person or date range does the decision concern? Which parts remain open?Avoid treating a decision about one component as a decision about everything.
3. FactsWhat facts or records support the position? Identify the relevant report, invoice, estimate or other record and its date or version.Find a factual mismatch, outdated document or missing submission.
4. Stated basisIf the position relies on policy language, identify the provision and explain its application. Otherwise, explain the liability position or other stated reason.Distinguish a policy issue from a factual disagreement or valuation dispute.
5. AmountIf money is involved, show what is included, excluded or deducted, any relevant dates or quantities, prior payments and the resulting amount.Reconcile the explanation with the estimate, bill, offer or payment.

These fields work together. “The limit was reached” is a stated reason, but it leaves questions about which limit, the applicable period and payments counted toward it. “The shop’s estimate is too high” does not identify the operation, quantity or rate in dispute. “Liability remains under investigation” describes a pending issue; it does not explain what has already been decided about coverage or another claim component.

Ask for the information needed to understand your issue. A request for an entire claim file, all internal communications and every policy held by another person is different from a focused decision request. Access to those materials can have separate rules and restrictions.

Do not turn an unclear answer into a denial

Labels are less useful than the action they describe. When an answer is ambiguous, ask the insurer to clarify it before building a response around an assumption.

Common responses and the missing question
Response receivedWhat remains uncertainFocused question
“We are still reviewing.”The unresolved issue and outstanding information.Which item remains pending, what information is needed, and who is expected to supply it?
“We issued payment.”Whether payment addresses the whole item, one part, or an initial estimate.What does this payment cover, and which submitted items remain unpaid or undecided?
“That is not covered.”The coverage or other basis for refusal.Is this a policy-based denial, a liability position, or an amount dispute? Please explain the applicable basis.
“That is our offer.”Its scope and any conditions of acceptance.Which claims and expenses would this offer resolve, and what documents or release would accompany it?
“The file is closed.”What that administrative label means for the specific request.Was this item decided, withdrawn, paid or closed for another reason? Please identify the decision and date.

Receiving a claim number or an acknowledgment is not the same thing as receiving a coverage decision. Likewise, a payment explanation should not be assumed to address expenses that it never mentions. Keep your worksheet marked “unanswered” until the response actually addresses the field.

An open document folder and loose papers on a desk beside a computer
Keep the request, earlier correspondence and the insurer’s response together. Illustrative stock photograph of office paperwork, not an actual claim file. Photo: Kampus Production / Pexels · License.

A request you can adapt after a phone conversation

Use the insurer’s verified claim email, secure portal or other designated correspondence address. Replace the brackets below, remove irrelevant questions and keep a copy of the message as sent.

Subject: Claim [number] — written explanation of [specific item]

Hello [name or claims team],

During our conversation on [date], I understood you to say [brief, neutral summary]. I am asking you to confirm or correct that understanding in writing.

For [specific expense, coverage or claim component], please explain:

  1. The current decision and whether any part remains pending.
  2. The exact items and dates the decision covers, and anything it does not address.
  3. The facts and records relied on, including the relevant document dates or versions.
  4. The applicable policy provision and how it applies, if this is a policy-based position; otherwise, the liability position or other reason.
  5. Any amount approved, offered or refused, with the calculation, deductions and prior payments needed to understand it.

If more information is needed, please identify the particular item, who is expected to provide it and the secure way to send it. Please also identify the person handling any portion outside your responsibility.

I have attached [document names and dates] because they relate to [specific question]. Please confirm receipt and tell me when I should expect the written explanation.

Thank you,
[name and appropriate contact information]

This asks for an explanation; it is not a formal appeal, proof of loss or substitute for a required claim form. Asking for an expected reply date does not create a legal response deadline. Continue addressing applicable claim requirements while seeking clarification.

Attach evidence for the unanswered field

The most useful attachment is the one that answers the specific question under review. If the insurer used an old repair estimate, identify the later version and the changed line items. If the question is rental dates, identify the rental invoice and relevant repair or authorization dates. Avoid sending a large unsorted folder and expecting the reader to find the contradiction.

Add a short attachment list: filename, date, relevant page and the issue it addresses. Preserve originals. If you resend something previously submitted, include the earlier submission date and ask whether it was considered. A portal receipt proves a submission was recorded; it does not, by itself, prove the reviewer examined every attachment.

For a payment based on a repair estimate, distinguish the original estimate from a later request for additional work. Our guide to hidden damage and repair supplements explains how to keep those records separate. That avoids treating a supplement still under review as though it were already included in the initial payment.

Use a verified secure route for sensitive documents. Do not include Social Security numbers, complete bank-account details or unrelated medical records in a routine request for a decision explanation. If particular sensitive information is requested, clarify its purpose and delivery method. This is about limiting unrelated disclosure, not refusing information genuinely needed for the claim.

Two short variations for partial and pending decisions

When a payment does not match the submitted amount

For claim [number], please identify which items in [invoice or estimate, date/version] are included in the payment dated [date]. Please explain each excluded or reduced item, the stated reason and the calculation. Please also identify any submitted items still pending and any prior payment or deductible included in your reconciliation.

Keep the payment amount, invoice total and disputed difference in separate fields. A difference is a question to reconcile, not proof of an underpayment. It may involve a deduction, an unreviewed item or another explanation that needs checking.

When the explanation only says more information is needed

Your message dated [date] says [item] remains under review. Please identify the issue that prevents a decision, the particular information still needed, and who is expected to provide it. Please confirm whether [document], submitted on [date], was received and considered. Please explain which portions, if any, have already been decided.

A pending-information request should help identify the next action. If the insurer wants something you do not possess, say that accurately and ask what alternative documentation it will consider. Do not invent a record or describe an estimate as a paid bill.

A woman standing beside a desk and reading several paper documents
Compare the response with the specific questions in your request before deciding what to ask next. Illustrative stock photograph; not a client, insurer representative or claim decision. Photo: Mizuno K / Pexels · License.

Read the reply against your five fields

Save the reply and its attachments together, including the date received. A portal message may refer to an estimate stored elsewhere in the account; download the referenced version so you can compare it with your own copy.

Mark each worksheet field answered, incomplete or disputed. These are different. “The insurer deducted the stated deductible” might answer the calculation question even if you dispute whether that deductible should apply. “The payment is correct” gives you no calculation to inspect.

Then check connections between fields. Does the policy reference relate to the expense actually refused? Does the stated record date match the version you sent? Does the calculation include the same period described in the decision? Is an item labeled pending in one attachment but denied in another?

If the issue is the vehicle’s value, request or locate the valuation supporting the amount before arguing from the final number alone. The total-loss valuation audit guide offers a separate way to inspect vehicle details, comparable vehicles and adjustments. The goal here is to obtain the explanation and underlying calculation, not perform the entire valuation dispute in the same letter.

Example: a rental payment with an unclear cutoff

Hypothetical correspondence example: On October 20, 2026, a driver receives a payment explanation referring to rental charges through October 12. The driver’s submitted invoice also lists October 13–15. A phone note says only “rental handled.” This example concerns how to clarify records; it does not establish coverage for any day.

The driver writes: “Please explain whether the charges for October 13–15 were denied, excluded from this payment pending review, or not yet considered. Please identify the reason for the October 12 cutoff, any applicable policy provision or other basis, and the dates and daily amounts used in the payment.”

The reply confirms that the later dates remain pending because the reviewer needs the shop’s repair-status record. The driver marks “decision” as answered for those dates: pending. The unanswered issue is now the missing record, rather than a presumed denial. The driver asks the shop for the identified record and retains the submission confirmation.

If the reply instead says those dates were refused, the next question concerns the stated cutoff and basis. If it says the entire invoice was paid, the next step is reconciling the listed dates and amounts. The same initial paperwork can lead to three different follow-ups; the written explanation tells you which one is appropriate.

For the separate questions about daily limits, authorization and rental periods, see rental-car coverage limits during repairs. A decision request does not extend a rental authorization or prevent additional rental charges from accruing.

What state guidance does—and does not—establish

Requesting a written explanation is useful nationwide. The insurer’s specific duties depend on the applicable state rules, policy and type of claim. These examples explain why identifying the relationship and decision matters; they are not a national timetable.

North Carolina: ask for the reason tied to the decision

The North Carolina Department of Insurance’s auto FAQs say a company must give a reasonable explanation for a denial in relation to policy language or applicable law. The relevant FAQ does not say that every decision must be delivered in writing. Your request can ask for that explanation in writing without overstating what this source requires.

Texas: distinguish the other driver’s insurer from your own

The Texas Department of Insurance’s other-driver claims guide recommends asking for a detailed written explanation when that insurer will not pay. It also explains that you do not have a contract with the other driver’s insurer. Ask whether the position concerns responsibility, coverage or the amount, rather than assuming your own policy’s process applies.

Washington: read the current rule and its scope

For a first-party claim—seeking payment as a covered person under a policy—WAC 284-30-380 addresses written policy-based denials and references to the specific provision, condition or exclusion. It separately addresses denials for other reasons, which can be communicated otherwise with a record in the insurer’s file. It also addresses notices when more time is needed. Do not assume every oral refusal fits the same rule.

WAC 284-30-350 requires disclosure of pertinent benefits, coverages and policy provisions to first-party claimants. That is not a universal right for a third-party claimant to receive another person’s entire policy.

These references were checked against the amendments effective October 18, 2026, in Washington’s permanent adoption notice. The timing provisions have their own scope and exceptions, including specified exceptions for medical professional liability claims. This guide supplies no deadline calculation or conclusion about retroactive application to an earlier claim.

A January calendar on a clipboard beside a clock, pencil and glasses
Record when you sent the request, when the response arrived and any deadline actually stated. Illustrative stock photograph; the calendar does not show a claim deadline. Photo: Marko Klaric / Pexels · License.

Follow up on the missing answer, not the entire claim

If the response answers four fields but omits the calculation, identify that omission directly. For example: “Thank you for identifying the applicable period. Please now show the daily amounts and deductions used to reach the payment, and identify the treatment of invoice line 6.” That gives the next reviewer a manageable question.

If two documents conflict, quote the short conflicting statements, identify their dates and ask which reflects the current position. Do not silently replace an earlier letter in your records. Keeping both helps explain why clarification was needed.

If the assigned adjuster cannot answer, ask for the appropriate supervisor or review team and forward the concise request with the relevant reply. If the explanation remains unresolved, your state insurance department can explain its complaint process and jurisdiction.

The Texas complaint guide illustrates the limits: the department cannot decide who caused an accident and cannot simply compel a payment without a violation of law or policy. A regulator inquiry may help obtain or examine an insurer’s response; it is not a guaranteed award or a substitute for resolving every private dispute.

Build a short review packet—not a stack of unanswered emails

If the reply still leaves a significant dispute, collect the materials that let someone understand it without starting the entire claim over. Lead with the decision and the precise point you want reviewed. Keep the supporting history behind that summary.

  1. The actual position: Include the complete letter or message and attachments, with the date received. If the position was oral, include your dated note and request written confirmation.
  2. The disputed item: Identify the expense, period or claim component. Keep an accepted repair item separate from a disputed injury or wage issue.
  3. The comparison: Put the insurer's statement beside the relevant record. Point to the exact page, date or calculation that appears inconsistent.
  4. The unresolved question: Say whether the answer is missing, incomplete or understood but disputed.
  5. The next deadline: Include any notice, offer, release or correspondence containing a response requirement. Do not assume a review request stops that clock.

Fictional example: A letter says a payment includes an entire invoice, but the attached calculation lists only three of four service dates. The reviewer does not have to decide the whole claim to identify the question: was the fourth date excluded, left pending or accidentally omitted from the calculation? The packet includes the full invoice, payment explanation and that one sentence.

If the insurer identifies a policy provision instead, bring the complete applicable form and endorsement—not a cropped sentence. If it disputes a fact, identify the record bearing on that fact. Each issue needs its own support; repeating that the amount feels low does not explain the discrepancy.

This packet can support a focused discussion with the insurer, an appropriate regulator or, when legal advice is needed, an attorney. Those recipients have different roles. Keep their questions and responses separate so a regulator inquiry is not mistaken for representation or a promise of payment.

Download a response audit you can keep with the actual letters

The five-field worksheet identifies the answer you need. The next job is preserving how that answer changes. Use this blank claim-decision response audit (text file) to put two replies beside their supporting documents. Save a copy on your own device or print it. The file is an original organizing aid, not an appeal form, and this website has no facility for receiving your completed version.

Give each decision its own row. Record the letter's date, date received, attachment names and exact question answered. Keep the original letter even when a later reply appears to replace it. A short version label such as “Reply A — November 4” makes it possible to refer to the right document without rewriting the insurer's words.

Next, classify the change: new information supplied; calculation changed; explanation clarified; position unchanged; or unclear. These are your file labels, not legal conclusions. A changed amount does not by itself show why it changed, and a clearer explanation does not mean you accepted the decision. Where the newer reply conflicts with an older one, ask which position applies now and what record explains the difference.

Fictional example: Reply A says a repair operation was omitted because the reviewer had not received a photograph. Reply B says the operation was reviewed but excluded for another stated reason. Record both reasons and their dates. Your next message can ask whether the photograph was received, whether Reply B replaces Reply A, and where the new reason is explained. Do not mark the issue resolved just because a second message arrived.

Use the audit's outcome column to distinguish answer obtained, still missing and understood but disputed. The first may complete a clarification task without ending a disagreement. The last should point to the exact fact, policy passage or calculation you need reviewed. This is more useful to a supervisor or adviser than a folder labeled “insurer ignored me” when the actual problem is an answer you dispute.

If you consider a regulator complaint, check that agency's role before choosing a requested outcome. For example, Texas's auto-complaint guidance explains that TDI regulates insurers and certain insurance professionals, but does not decide crash fault or handle body-shop complaints. That is a Texas example, not a promise that every state agency can resolve the same dispute. Keep the agency reference and any legal or policy deadline separate from the informal follow-up date on your audit.

The worksheet deliberately asks for document references rather than medical details, identification numbers or banking information. Fill only what is useful in your private copy. If you share it, use the verified channel of the insurer, regulator or lawyer handling the particular issue. Downloading it does not submit a claim, extend a deadline or request representation.

Before acting on the explanation

Separate understanding a decision from agreeing to it. If an offer includes a release, ask which claims the release covers and review the actual document. Do not assume a label such as “property damage only” describes everything in the accompanying terms.

A clarification request does not automatically pause a filing deadline, extend a policy time limit, preserve every claim or replace a required notice. Likewise, a pending explanation does not establish that ongoing rental, storage or other costs will be paid. Address time-sensitive issues separately.

If an injury claim or proposed release is part of the dispute, get your own questions addressed before deciding what to accept. Bring the written decision, supporting records and any settlement terms to a review. You can ask what remains unresolved and what the next legal step could involve without claiming the paperwork guarantees a result. Explore a free injury case review.

Your next step

Do not make a settlement decision around an unexplained answer.

If you were injured in the crash and a disputed payment or proposed release has left you with questions, bring the actual documents to a free injury case review and discuss your options.

Get my case-review options →Free initial review through an independent provider. No obligation to hire.

Sources and scope

Core sources checked October 22, 2026; editorial update November 4, 2026. State examples apply only to the named jurisdiction. This guide is editorially researched; it has not been reviewed by an attorney and does not assess your individual claim.

  1. NAIC: What You Should Know About Filing an Auto Claim
  2. North Carolina Department of Insurance: FAQs About Auto Insurance
  3. Texas Department of Insurance: How to Deal With the Other Driver's Insurance
  4. Washington WAC 284-30-380: Settlement Standards Applicable to All Insurers
  5. Washington WAC 284-30-350: Misrepresentation of Policy Provisions
  6. Washington State Register 26-17-089: Permanent Claims-Handling Rules
  7. Texas Department of Insurance: Auto Insurance Complaints

Spot an error? Contact support@injurylawadvisor.us with the page and source. Please do not email medical records or sensitive case details.