Start with the missed shift or changed assignment. For tips, match the checkout and tip-pool statement to the amount you kept. For commissions, match the sale or credit date to the later pay statement. Identify what was paid, where it appears twice, and which missed earnings are still an estimate.
What you can do with this guide
- Pair the originally assigned shift with the hours and duties actually worked.
- Trace cash, card tips, pool movements and deferred commission payments without counting a payment twice.
- Present comparable shifts separately and identify any work or sales credit the employer could not confirm.
Start with a shift you can actually identify
The Friday after the collision, your pay lands in the bank as usual. You missed both weekend dinner shifts. Looking at that deposit, someone could reasonably ask what pay you missed. The answer may be in last week's tip settlement and next week's payroll. Start with the first affected shift and find out which pay statement would ordinarily include it. Some tips may have left the building with you at closing. Others may reach your account days later.
Write the date, scheduled start and end, assignment, and what actually happened. An originally posted schedule can establish that you were assigned the patio from five to close. A later schedule may show only the person who covered it. Save your own dated copy of the first version and the message confirming the change. If there was no advance assignment, describe what you know. Being available for a shift and being assigned one are different facts.
Keep a line for each employer. Someone who sells appliances during the week and serves at a restaurant every other Saturday has two payroll calendars and two systems for sharing or crediting earnings. Combining the deposits makes it hard to see which job changed. Use the missed-work and payroll records guide for ordinary hours, pay periods and employer confirmation. This worksheet adds what payroll alone can miss when a job pays tips or commissions.
Find the record behind each amount
- Schedule and actual hours. Pair the scheduled assignment with a time entry or supervisor confirmation. Write down a transfer from serving to hosting, an early departure or a shift swap. Someone can work their usual hours in a different assignment with a different opportunity for tips.
- Shift checkout or tip statement. Ask whether the register displays all tips charged to your checks, the amount allocated to you after the pool, or the amount still payable. The column headings matter. A report for the whole restaurant will rarely answer a question about one person's earnings.
- Daily tip record. Look for the entries you made at the time for cash, charged tips, amounts shared with coworkers and amounts received from a pool. The IRS describes these records in Publication 531. A late recollection can explain where to look. Date it when you write it and keep it separate from the original entries.
- Commission statement and plan. Ask which transaction or milestone produced the credit, which plan applied at the time, and which pay statement carried it. The sale amount and the commission payable to an individual are different figures. A team sale may also be divided among employees.
If a claim reviewer asks for payroll records, ask which dates they want and whether they need a shift breakdown, gross earnings or verification from the employer. Federal payroll record rules for employees covered by 29 CFR 516.2 distinguish hours, additions and deductions, wages paid, the date of payment and the period covered. These fields can guide a narrow request. Your employer's available reports and the claim reviewer's documentation requirements may differ.

Follow one worked shift through the tip pool
Here is a fictional shift with all the necessary records available. On Thursday, the checkout shows $180 in customer card tips before sharing. The server's dated log shows $35 in voluntary cash tips. The pool statement shows a $42 contribution and a separate $12 distribution to the server. The records support $185 in tips retained for that shift. The restaurant paid the card and pool portion later. The arithmetic works because the $180 starts before pool changes and the $12 is a separate credit. With a checkout that already displays the final employee share, subtracting $42 again would give the wrong answer.
Suppose payroll confirms that the $150 net card and pool amount from that shift appears on Friday's tip payment. The server had already kept the other $35 in cash. The complete shift still shows $185. Beside the $150 payroll line write “payment of Thursday tips” and reference the shift row. A payroll system may also display tips already taken in cash so payroll can account for them. Ask how the specific line affected the actual payment before treating it as new money.
Banquet work can look different. A contracted service charge on an event bill and a voluntary cash tip left at the table may both appear under a heading like “gratuity.” The IRS and the Department of Labor distinguish a compulsory service charge from a discretionary tip. Where an employer distributes part of that charge, keep the employee's documented wage line separate from voluntary tips. A photo of the charge on the customer's check says nothing on its own about how much reached the employee.
Annual totals can help identify a missing record. For example, a W-2 may have a separate Box 8 amount for allocated tips at certain establishments. Ask payroll which annual figure you are looking at. A Box 8 allocation cannot identify the tips taken home on a particular Friday. For an accident-related record request, take the pay period and shift as your starting point and leave tax-return questions to a qualified preparer.

Trace a commission paid after the crash
A salesperson books an order on March 3, misses work March 10 through 14 and receives a $360 commission on March 14. Did the salesperson work during the absence? The bank deposit cannot answer. In this fictional example, the plan in effect credits the sale on delivery. The delivery record shows March 7, the commission statement references the same order, and payroll places that $360 on the March 14 check. The deposit is real. The linked records explain why it arrived during the absence.
For your own record, create spaces for the work or order date, the milestone payroll uses under the plan, the date the commission appeared on the statement and the date it was paid. Copy the wording your employer uses for the credit. If the plan changed, preserve the version that applied. Ask sales operations to confirm the connection using a masked transaction reference. A customer's identity, contact details and purchase history are rarely what the reviewer needs to follow a commission entry.
Some commissions take longer to determine than the regular payroll cycle. The federal overtime rule at 29 CFR 778.119 addresses deferred commissions when its overtime provisions apply. It illustrates why the period in which a commission was earned can differ from payday. It does not tell a particular worker when an accident claim is payable. Use your employee plan, itemized statement and payroll explanation to date each entry.
What about an order that you expected to close? Suppose a colleague takes over a scheduled appointment and the customer later buys. Save the appointment assignment and any documented change in sales credit. Until the sales office confirms what happened and which plan applied, enter “appointment reassigned, credit unknown.” A verbal estimate, a quote that expired and a credited sale belong on different lines. If there was a credit and it was later reversed on a return, cross-reference the original and the reversal. Record the reason only when the statement or employer confirms it.
Choose comparable shifts you can explain
Take a missed Saturday dinner shift. Pull earlier Saturdays with the same role, similar hours, and the same pool arrangement. Record which dates you looked at and why. Include an ordinary quiet shift alongside a strong one. A holiday buyout, a shorter training shift or a temporary patio closure may explain a very different number. Keep unusual dates visible with that explanation so another reader can follow your selection.
Imagine two prior dinner shifts with records showing $117 and $199 in retained tips. A third Saturday was a private party with service-charge wages. Display each separately with its start time, hours and assignment. The $117 and $199 are observations for those two nights. There was no customer checkout for your missed dinner shift. Leave its actual tip field blank and mark the shift missed. Label any requested comparison as an estimate and identify the records and method used. Ask the recipient which comparison period or documentation they accept before extrapolating.
Comparisons need extra care after a return to lighter duties. A bartender who came back for three host shifts might receive a smaller share per hour or no pool share under that assignment. Record actual host hours, actual share, and when that assignment began. Compare those dates separately from dates completely missed. If discussing a change of duties with your employer, use the return-to-work duty comparison to identify when the change started and who confirmed the assignment.

What to ask payroll when the numbers disagree
Send a request someone can answer by checking a single statement. For example, “For my Thursday dinner shift on June 4, the checkout says $180 in card tips. Which line on the June 12 pay statement includes my share? Does the checkout figure include the tip pool adjustment? Could you confirm the period covered and explain how tips I took in cash appear on this statement?” For commission work, substitute the masked order reference, credit date and amount. Ask for an employee-only extract if the underlying report identifies customers or coworkers.
If payroll cannot retrieve shift-level detail, specify the gap. A supervisor may confirm that a date was a dinner shift. Payroll may confirm the total tips distributed for the entire pay period. Keep those two answers as they arrived. Dividing the period total evenly across every shift creates figures no one confirmed. If a till report was corrected, save both versions and the date of the correction. If a coworker covered the shift but will not share personal earnings, the original schedule can still establish the staffing change.
Record sick pay, vacation, a wage advance or other payments under their actual payroll labels. An advance against future commissions can make cash flow look steady until a later statement reconciles it. Ask which line records that later adjustment. Leave questions about offsets, entitlement or accident responsibility for the relevant decision maker. Mixing an advance, its repayment and a later commission into one total makes the original period harder to explain.
Build a short packet for the person reviewing your records
Download the printable shift and commission worksheet. Fill it out on paper or in a text editor on your own device. It includes separate spaces for scheduled work, verified receipts, comparison shifts and the later payroll entry. It has no upload or send function. Label each supporting record with a short reference such as “shift 2” or “commission statement B.” Keep unredacted originals privately. Use a working copy with account numbers and unrelated employee or customer details removed when preparing an initial summary.
Read it once from the point of view of someone who has never worked at your business. Can they find the original shift, see which payments cover it, and tell which number remains unknown? If a payment is visible twice, draw a line between the two records. If a date was swapped for another shift, cross-reference both dates and include the work you actually did. Put one question at the top of the packet, such as “Which documents do you accept for the two missed shifts with no individual checkout?” Save a dated copy of what you sent and the reply.
This guide covers U.S. employee record organization. If you operated your own business, the self-employment income records guide addresses jobs, expenses and receipts. For a New York no-fault claim, the New York lost-earnings guide covers the employee and employer paperwork. If an injury-related claim still has an unresolved earnings question, you can explore a free case review with your schedule and summary in hand.
Your next step
Did an injury change the shifts you could work?
Bring your dates, pay statements and any unresolved earnings questions to a free case review with an independent provider.
Explore My Legal Options →Free initial review through an independent provider. No obligation to hire.Sources and scope
Core sources checked November 13, 2026; editorial update November 13, 2026. State examples apply only to the named jurisdiction. This guide is editorially researched; it has not been reviewed by an attorney and does not assess your individual claim.
- IRS, Tip Recordkeeping and Reporting
- IRS Publication 531, Reporting Tip Income
- 29 CFR § 516.2, payroll records for covered employees
- 29 CFR § 531.55, compulsory service charges
- 29 CFR § 778.119, deferred commission payments
Spot an error? Contact support@injurylawadvisor.us with the page and source. Please do not email medical records or sensitive case details.
